By Michael Greger
12-29-03
(First published 6-16-96)
If indeed a form of Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) exists in the
United States, one might expect to see a rise in the number of cases of
Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD). CJD, however, is not a reportable illness
in this country (Holman, 1995). Because the Centers for Disease Control
(CDC) does not actively monitor the disease (Altman, 1996d) a rise similar
to the one in Britain could be missed (Altman, 1996d). Already, a number
of U.S. CJD clusters have been found. In the largest known U.S. outbreak
of sporadic cases to date(Flannery, 1996) a five-fold expected rate was
found to be associated with cheese consumption in Pennsylvania's Lehigh
Valley (Little, 1993) A striking increase in CJD was also reported in
Florida (Berger, 1994) and there is an anecdotal report of an cluster in
Oregon (Boule, 1996). An analysis of death certificates in a number of
states, though, showed an overall stable and typical CJD incidence rate
from 1979 to 1993 (World, 1996). To track the disease, the CDC has just
initiated a four-state study of death certificates (Altman, 1996a), but
since it is considered well known that death-certificate diagnoses are not
always accurate (Davanpour, 1993) the survey may not provide an accurate
assessment.
The true prevalence of prion diseases in this or any other country remains
a mystery (Harrison, 1991). Compounding the uncertainty, autopsies are
rarely performed on atypical dementias (Harrison, 1991), because medical
professionals fear infection (Altman, 1996a). The officially reported rate
in this country is less than 1 case in a million people per year (World,
1996). An informal survey of neuropathologists, however, registered a
theoretical range of 2-12% of all dementias as actually CJD (Harrison,
1991). And hundreds of thousands of Americans suffer from severe dementias
every year (Brayne, 1994; United, 1995). Two other studies average about a
3% CJD rate among dementia patients (Mahendra, 1987; Wade, 1987). A
preliminary 1989 University of Pennsylvania study showed that 5% of
patients diagnosed with dementia were actually dying from
Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (Boller, 1989). It would seem CJD is seriously
underdiagnosed at present (Harrison, 1991).
The most common misdiagnosis of CJD is Alzheimer's disease (Harrison,
1991). CJD was even described by our government's top CJD researcher (Wlazelek,
1990a) as "Alzheimer's in fast forward (Wlazelek, 1990b)." The symptoms
and pathology of both diseases overlap (Brown, 1989). There can be spongy
changes in Alzheimer's, for example, and senile plaques in CJD (Brown,
1989). The causes may overlap as well; epidemiological evidence suggests
that people eating meat more than four times a week for a prolonged period
have a three times higher chance of suffering a dementia than long-time
vegetarians (Giem, 1993), although this result may be confounded by
vascular factors (Van Duijn, 1996).
Paul Brown, medical director for the U.S. Public Health Service (Gruzen,
1996), said that the brains of the young people who died from the new CJD
variant in Britain even look like Alzheimer's brains (Hager, 1996).
Stanley Prusinger, the scientist who coined the term prion, speculates
Alzheimer's may in fact turn out to be a prion disease (Prusiner, 1984).
In younger victims the disease could look like multiple sclerosis or a
severe viral infection, according to Alzheimer's expert Gareth Roberts
(Brain, 1996).
An estimated two to three million Americans are afflicted by Alzheimer's
(Scully, 1993); it is the fourth leading cause of death among the elderly
in the U.S (Perry, 1995). Twenty percent or more of people clinically
diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease are found at autopsy to not have had
Alzheimer's at all (McKhann, 1984). At Yale, out of 46 patients clinically
diagnosed with Alzheimer's, 6 were proven to be CJD at autopsy (Manuelidis,
1989). In another post-mortem study 3 out of 12 "Alzheimer" patients
actually died from a spongiform encephalopathy (Teixeira, 1995).
Carleton Gajdusek, who was awarded a Nobel Prize for his work with prion
diseases (Manuelidis, 1985), estimates that 1% of people showing up in
Alzheimer clinics actually have CJD (Folstein, 1983). That means that
hundreds of people (Hoyert, 1996; United, 1995) may already be dying from
mad cow disease each year in the United States.
WORKS CITED
Altman, Lawrence K. "Four States Watching for Brain Disorder." New York
Times, 9 April 1996a.
Altman, Lawrence K. "U.S. Officials Confident That Mad Cow Disease of
Britain Has Not Occured Here." New York Times, 27 March 1996d: 12A.
"Apocalypse Cow: U.S. Denials Deepen Mad Cow Danger." PR Watch, 3.1
(1996): 1-8
Berger, Joseph R., et al. "Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease: A Ten-Year
Experience." Neurology, 44 (1994): A260.
Bleifuss, Joel. "Killer Beef." In These Times, 31 May 1993: 12-15.
Boller, F., O. L. Lopez, and J. Moossy. "Diagnosis of Dementia."
Neurology, 38 (1989): 76-79.
Boule, Margie. "Despite Anectdotal Evidence, Docs Say No Mad Cow Disease
Here." Oregonian, 16 April 1996: C01.
"Brain Disease May Be Commoner Than Thought - Expert." Reuter Information
Service, 15 May 1996.
Brayne, C. "How Common are Cognitive Impairment and Dementia?" Dementia
and Normal Aging, Canbridge: University Press, 1994.
Brown, Paul. "Central Nervous System Amyloidoses." Neurology, 39 (1989):
1103-1104.
Davanpour, Zoreth, et al. "Rate of Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease in USA."
Neurology, 43 (1993): A316.
Flannery, Mary. "Twelve - Fifteen 'Mad Cow' Victims a Year in Area."
Philadelphia Daily News, 26 March 1996: 03.
Folstein, M. "The Cognitive Pattern of Familial Alzheimer's Disease."
Biological Aspects of Alzheimer's Disease. Ed. R. Katzman. Cold Spring
Harbor Laboratory, 1983.
Gruzen, Tara. "Sheep Parts Fail to Cause Mad Cow Disease in U. S. Test."
Seattle Times, 29 March 1996: A11.
Hager, Mary and Mark Hosenball. "'Mad Cow Disease' in the U.S.?" Newsweek,
8 April 1996:58-59.
Harrison, Paul J., and Gareth W. Roberts. "'Life, Jim, But Not as We Know
It'? Transmissible Dementias and the Prion Protein." British Journal of
Psychiatry, 158 (1991): 457-70.
Holman, R. C., et al. "Edidemiology of Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease in the
United States, 1979-1990." Neuroepidemiology, 14 (1995): 174-181.
Hoyert, Donna L. "Vital and Health Statistics. Mortality Trends for
Alzheimer's Disease, 1979-1991." Washington: U.S. Dept. of Health and
Human Services, 1996.
Little, Brian W., et al. "The Epidemiology of Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease in
Eastern Pennsylvania." Neurology, 43 (1993): A316.
Mahendra, B. Dementia, Lancaster: MTP Press Limited, 1987: 174.
Manuelidis, Elias E. "Presidential Address." Journal of Neuropathology and
Experimental Neurology, 44 (1985): 1-17.
Manuelidis, Elias E. and Laura Manuelidis. "Suggested Links between
Different Types of Dementias: Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease, Alzheimer
Disease, and Retroviral CNS Infections." Alzheimer Disease and Associated
Disorders, 2 (1989): 100-109.
McKhann, Guy., et al. "Clinical Diagnosis of Alzheimer's Disease."
Neurology, 34 (1984): 939.
Prusiner, S. "Some Speculations about Prions, Amyloid, and Alzheimer's
Disease." New England Journal of Medicine, 310 (1984): 661-663.
Perry, R.T., et al. "Human Prion Protein Gene: Two Different 24 BP
Deletions in an Atypical Alzheimer's Disease Family." American Journal of
Medical Genetics, 60 (1995): 12-18.
Scully, R. E., et al. "Case Records of the Massachusetts General
Hospital." New England Journal of Medicine, 29 April 1993: 1259-1263.
Teixeira, F., et al. "Clinico-Pathological Correlation in Dementias."
Journal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience, 20 (1995): 276-282.
United States Department of Commerce. Statistical Abstract of the United
States, Washington: Bureau of the Census, 1995.
Van Duijn, C. M. "Epidemiology of the Dementia: Recent Developments and
New Approaches." Neuroepidemiology, 60 (1996): 478-488.
Van Duijn, C. M. "Epidemiology of the Dementia: Recent Developments and
New Approaches." Neuroepidemiology, 60 (1996): 478-488.
Wade, J. P. H., et al. "The Clinical Diagnosis of Alzheimer's Disease."
Archives of Neurology, 44 (1987): 24-29.
Wlazelek, Ann. "Fatal Brain Disease Mystifies Experts." Morning Call, 23
September 1990a: B01.
Wlazelek, Ann. "Scientists Try to Track Fatal Disease; International
Expert Visits Area to Study Unusual Incedence Rate." Morning Call, 27
September 1990b: B04.
"World Health Organization Consultatoin on Public Health Issues Related to
Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy and the Emergence of a New Variant of
Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease.", Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 12
April 1996: 295-303.
http://www.cyber-dyne.com/~tom/Alzheimer_cjd.html#and%20C
FAIR
USE NOTICE. This document contains copyrighted material whose use
has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner.
GeoCrisis is making this article available in our efforts to
advance the understanding of environmental, justice issues, corporate
accountability, human rights, labor rights and social understanding. We
believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish
to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go
beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.